« Twitter roundup | Main | Does Obama face a racial double standard? »

September 28, 2011

Comments

RE: Scare Quotes Continue to Plague Journal Editorial WritersS

Chait simple-mindedly writes:

A nice example can be found in Daniel Henninger's column today:

Barack Obama and his perpetually angry Democratic "base" are the outliers on comprehensive tax reform.


To a normal English speaker, this formulation would signify that Henninger disputes the existence of a Democratic base. In Journal-ese, he's just saying he doesn't like Democrats.

I can't read the whole WSJ story since it is behind a pay-wall, but it's seems more likely a "normal English speaker" would understand Henninger uses scare-quotes to indicate he disagrees with the implied definition of "base" than to imply it doesn't exist.

I am always puzzled when you link to Chait, Brendan, as he has a greater propensity than most writers to be-clown himself.

I'm glad to see Brendan point out an example of bad fact-checking. However, sometimes fact-checkers get it right. Glenn Kessler at WaPo, accurately debunked what he calls "a bogus chart on Obama and the debt." Brendan linked to a version of this chart some time ago.

Kessler writes:

...a chart, purporting to show how Republican presidents — Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush — had increased the debt by a significantly greater percentage than either Bill Clinton or President Obama. Pretty impressive chart, “liked” by at least 7,000 people on a posting by the liberal group MoveOn.org.

But this chart, originally created by the office of House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, is as phony as a three-dollar bill. Our friends at PolitiFact did a pretty thorough takedown of it in May, giving it their worst rating: “pants on fire.” They even caught the Pelosi people in a bad mathematical error, based on the fact that the Democrats calculated the numbers as if Obama took office a year later than he did.

http://voices.washingtonpost.com/fact-checker/2011/01/judges_letter_on_health_care.html

The comments to this entry are closed.